3rd Quarter Update

Dear Friends,

I hope this email finds you and your family well. It has been a busy couple of weeks around the virtual TAHSR office, so I wanted to update you on several key developments.

Texas Property Deeded To Japanese

As you may have heard in the news recently, Texas Central filed a Deed of Trust in each County in which it owns property. While the amount of property Texas Central owns is still quite small in terms of track mileage, the company has deeded all that property as collateral to Japan Texas High-Speed Rail Cayman, an offshore account created in 2018 by the Japanese government as part of its $300M loan to the project. Because this deed of trust was never disclosed to landowners or our State Legislators during hearings about land acquisition, we sounded the alarm by releasing this statement.

Several of our state elected officials and Congressman Kevin Brady made statements on the issue as well. We created a brief overview you can see here:

that explains more about these deeds and includes links to the actual documents. Texas Central’s response was that this was a normal business practice. Do these Deeds of Trust violate landowner rights if they sold under threat of eminent domain? We are looking into this now.

Federal Railroad Administration Action

Did you see last week that Texas Central got two important approvals for their project? Not to worry. What the media called a “green light” for the project is anything but. The Federal Railroad Administration issued its Record of Decision (ROD), which is the final recommendation for Texas Central’s project based on the Environmental Impact Statement. It also issued a Rule of Particular Applicability (RPA), which was a special set of rules required for Texas Central because the trains the company is wanting to use do not meet current regulations for crashworthiness. Interestingly, the RPA is requiring Texas Central to redesign its trains, which will require a considerable amount of time and millions of dollars. The very fact that the ROD was issued allows for legal challenges to begin. So many of you attended public meetings and submitted comments about all the issues found within the Draft Environmental Impact Statement or blatant omissions. Most of those remained in the Final Environmental Impact Statement, giving plenty of opportunity for legal challenges. Here is an overview of the ROD and our statement about its release.

The bottom line is that the FRA does not give permission or approval for Texas Central to do anything and it stated that the project is still in a “conceptual stage.”

Following the FRA’s issuance of the ROD, Carma Sullivan gave a wonderful interview regarding her families property, which you can see here. 

So, what now? 

First, the Surface Transportation Board (STB), the federal entity that actually oversees railroad construction, has required Texas Central to submit a full application for its consideration. This means TCR has to provide final engineering and construction plans, as well as financial information. Given that the Federal Railroad Administration is now requiring a redesign of the trainsets, final designs are so far off there is no way construction will being “in the first half of next year” as was reported this week. Additionally, this will be the first time that the financial solvency and viability of the project will be under public scrutiny. We have been told this STB application is a years-long process. Given the state of the world economy and Texas Central’s coffers, we suspect showing their financials is the last thing they want to do.

Secondly, the Legislative Session is right around the corner in January. We intend to have a Capitol Day one way or another. There have been no guidelines issued regarding visitors to the Capitol and we don’t anticipate any specifics until January. However, we want to invite you to save the date for March 30, 2021. With the information that has come out about this proposed HSR that is in direct contradiction to what the legislators were told in the last session, we feel strongly that our voices will be heard. 

TUESDAY, MARCH 30, 2021 AT 6 AM – 6 PM
Stop the HSR Capitol Day
Click the image to share the Official Facebook Event!

And, lastly, the Texas Supreme Court was provided with briefs from Texas Farm Bureau, Texas & Southwestern Cattle Raisers Association, and, a real railroad, SNCF, in support of Jim Miles and his petition against Texas Central. You can read those in full here:

We are hoping to hear from the Texas Supreme Court in the next couple of months regarding their interest in the case. 

This year has been difficult in so many ways, but I am proud of how the Texans Against HSR team of volunteers and our steadfast dedicated team of legislative and legal experts have not waivered. While Texas Central was laying off the majority of its staff, our full team remained hard at work and didn’t miss a beat because we have operated virtually since our inception. 

To continue this work, we need your financial support. Whether you have $100 to spare, $1,000 or $10,000, the upcoming legal challenges and legislative session are paramount to our success. We need your help. Please give as generously as you can. We have to make decisions soon based on what resources we have available. You can donate here:

or mail a check to TAHSR, PO Box 245, Jewett Texas, 75846. We truly appreciate your continued support and thank you for your trust.

Truly for Texas,
Kyle Workman
Chair and President
Texans Against HSR

Remember these? We still have them available for you to show your support! Just send an email to desi@texansagainsthsr.com. Yard signs: $25 shipped. Banners: 8’x4′ – $175, 8’x3′ – $125, 4’x4′ – $75 shipped.

PRESS RELEASE September 15, 2020

Texas Central Railway Deeds Texas Property
To The Japanese Government

Jewett, TX – Despite its claim to be a Texas company building a Texas project to benefit the people of Texas, public documents show Texas Central Railway has deeded property from Texas landowners to the Japanese government through an offshore entity set up in the Cayman Islands.

Based on a series of recently recorded real property transactions in counties along the affected route, it appears the Japanese government required Texas Central to put up the land as collateral for the sizeable loan owed to them. In each county (Leon, Waller, Madison, Harris, Grimes, Dallas, Ellis, etc.), Texas Central filed a “Deed of Trust, Assignment of Leases and Rents, Security Agreement and Fixture Filing” relating to property owned by Texas Central in that county. The beneficiary of these Deeds of Trust is an offshore entity named “Japan Texas High-Speed Railway Cayman GP.” Texas Central did not disclose the existence of this offshore beneficiary to any of the landowners it convinced to sign an option contract. Nor did it disclose its plans to use the property purchased through the option contracts to secure a loan from the Japanese government.

Adding to the serious concern of several elected officials from the local to federal levels, Texans Against HSR chair and president, Kyle Workman, explained that this latest deceptive action is one in a long string that landowners need to be made aware of. “Texas Central has long touted itself as a Texas company and a Texas project. Yet, some of the first Texas property it acquired was immediately deeded to an offshore shell company created by the Japanese government.”

Workman continued, “If Texas Central had disclosed their intent to deed this property to the government of Japan, lawmakers and landowners most likely would have considered these real estate transactions differently. There are still landowners with pending option contracts with Texas Central…these Texans must be notified immediately that the property Texas Central has acquired is being used as collateral to secure a loan from a foreign government. We ask that the Governor support measures to protect Texas land from being deceptively acquired and transferred into the shadows of offshore ownership, beyond the regulatory protections of US and Texas law.”

While Texas Central Railway continues to claim it will begin construction next year, the company has recently laid off the majority of its staff, admitted the cost estimate for the project has ballooned to $30B, expressed its intent to seek federal funds for a project they have called “private” and “not needing any public funds,” and is now being required by the federal-level Surface Transportation Board to file a full application including financial and ridership information, which the company has refused to make public thus far.

Additionally, the Federal Railroad Administration is set to publish its Record of Decision (ROD) related to the Final Environmental Impact Statement (FEIS) for this HSR project on Friday. This ROD does not give the company the needed permission to construct; however, it is considered a final federal action for the project, allowing lawsuits regarding FEIS NEPA violations to begin.

###

PRESS RELEASE June 8, 2020

TEXAS CENTRAL RAILWAY SEEKING STIMULUS FUNDS

Texas Central Execs Explore Federal Dollars While Feds Limit Taxpayer

Jewett, Texas – New revelations regarding funding for the embattled Dallas Houston HSR have come to light over the last several days when a letter from Drayton McLane, Texas Central Railway’s Chairman and main investor, revealed that the project has “hit a snag” and is now estimated to cost $30B, which is a 300% cost increase since the project was first announced and a 150% increase from the project cost currently shown on the Federal Railroad Administration project dashboard. However, Texas Central is apparently not worried about this enormous cost increase because they “hope to receive [monies] from President Trump’s infrastructure stimulus through the Department of Transportation,” despite, for nearly a decade, touting the project to the public, elected officials, and the media as a “privately funded project” to create a more favorable public perception.

First to highlight the letter describing Texas Central’s changes in funding plans was a Dallas Business Journal’s article by Evan Hoopfer, who has closely followed the Dallas Houston HSR, reporting that in response to McLane’s letter, Carlos Aguilar, CEO of Texas Central, admitted, “We don’t know whether [private equity is] going to be there or not. It depends on the markets themselves to determine if and how much of the money can come from private equity. And that’s why it could require some stimulus money, but we don’t know yet.”

John Fund, a nationally-known and well-respected journalist who has often spoken out on the reality of this proposed HSR’s failed future, weighed in on the admission that the project will seek federal funding in an article entitled, “This Is Exactly the Wrong Time for Another High-Speed Train Boondoggle.” Fund explained that “government loans are often forgiven or forgotten, with taxpayers left holding the bag.”

Kyle Workman, Chairman and President of Texans Against HSR, said, “Texas Central has already used the pandemic to explain away laying off the majority of their staff, and now we find out they are using it to make up for their lack of private investment.” Workman added, “We’ve heard that Mr. McLane has been busy asking for every public funding opportunity available in DC. Stimulus funds, RRIF loans that are rarely paid back, and then, ironically timed, a former Texas Central employee now US Representative from Massachusetts recently authored a bill for $205B in funding for HSR, specifically including Texas Central’s project. The depths to which Texas Central will go to get public funds for their ‘private project’ reveals what we have known all along… this project cannot be privately funded.”

The timing of Texas Central’s shift to rely on public funding is underscored by the exclusion of public hearings on matters of safety and environmental impacts for this HSR project. Texas State Representative Ben Leman shared in his recent opinion editorial that he and other state legislators, as well as Texas’ own Department of Transportation, requested postponement of public hearings until a time that the public could fully participate in person. Instead, the Federal Railroad Administration moved forward with telephonic hearings that were poorly promoted and suffered connection issues. Rep. Leman said, “I hope you will join me in rising up in defense of democracy and protecting our taxpayer dollars. I ask you to call upon  [Transportation] Secretary Elaine Chao and ask why the USDOT is supporting Texas Central’s $30B proposed project, when Texas Central is seeking billions in taxpayer dollars, without adequate involvement from the very taxpayers potentially footing the bill.”

###

Download / Print

PRESS RELEASE May 8, 2020

COURT OF APPEALS HSR RULING SETS
DANGEROUS EMINENT DOMAIN PRECEDENT

Jewett, Texas – Jim and Barbara Miles, of Leon County, learned Thursday that in their legal fight  to protect their ranch and private property rights from the proposed high-speed rail project, the Corpus Christi Court of Appeals ruled in favor of Texas Central and its newly-formed affiliate ITL, stating that both entities are railroad companies and interurban electric railways under Texas law. While this ruling was not the outcome the Miles expected, the companies still cannot access or condemn their property, as the Miles will be appealing the ruling to the Texas Supreme Court.

Blake Beckham, the Miles’ attorney and Special Litigation Counsel to Texans Against HSR (TAHSR), said, “If ever there was a ruling that created ‘the Wild, Wild, West’ of eminent domain authority, this is it. This ruling creates a dangerous precedent that would allow anybody with $300 and a computer to immediately obtain the extraordinary power of eminent domain by simply filing papers with the Texas Secretary of State self-declaring to be a railroad. This is not and cannot be the law in Texas.”

Kyle Workman, Chairman and President of TAHSR, said, “We are disappointed the Court of Appeals treated these fundamental private property rights, cherished by all Texans, with such disregard. This project’s cost estimate is now at $30B, the company has laid off the majority of its staff and still does not have the plans, permits or funds to move forward, so this project is far from shovel-ready as they claim. Jim and Barbara Miles are still in this fight, and we are standing with them, as should all Texans who value private property rights.”

To have the original ruling by Judge Deborah Evans that Texas Central and ITL are not railroads or interurban electric railways upheld, Jim and Barbara Miles will appeal to the Texas Supreme Court, which has consistently and repeatedly recognized the importance of private property rights in Texas. “This Court of Appeals ruling has only strengthened our resolve to keep fighting to protect not only our property but the private property rights of all Texans. We are hopeful the Supreme Court will see how this ruling could open a Pandora’s Box of eminent domain issues in Texas. They simply cannot allow this Appeals Court ruling to stand.”

Landowners should know Texas Central still has no right on their private property at this time. While TAHSR suspects Texas Central will try to use this ruling to enter private property for surveys and other activities or try to secure additional funding for the project, until the Texas Supreme Court issues a final, unappealable ruling, Texas Central cannot condemn private property.

###

Download / Print

US Army Corps of Engineers Public Comment Notice

Friends,

Texans Against HSR has been working diligently on your behalf during this new and uncertain time. In stark contrast to Texas Central, our work has gone uninterrupted within the stronger-than-ever team made up of volunteers, the attorneys from the Beckham Group and our lobbyists in Austin and DC. Our elected officials, now busier than ever, have not forgotten our fight against the detrimental impacts of the proposed HSR. While those elected officials and Texans Against HSR have requested any and all public comment periods related to the proposed Dallas Houston HSR be postponed, TAHSR has received many questions about the US Army Corps of Engineers 404 permit public comment periods. 
 

Background

Since our state has been under the stay at home order, the US Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) and Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ) have opened two new public comment periods regarding the proposed Dallas Houston HSR for two separate 404 permits. Several elected officials have requested public hearings be conducted as part of these comment periods, and in doing so, also requested the postponement of the entire public comment period until a time that public hearings are both lawful and safe.  
 
Did you receive a packet of information from the USACE?
If you have recently received a packet of information regarding the US Army Corps of Engineers 404 permitting of the Dallas Houston HSR, below is a draft of possible comments for you to submit in the meantime while we await word on the rescheduling of the public comment periods, as well as pertinent contact information. Feel free to copy and paste this into your email and then edit or add to it as you feel necessary for your unique situation. The deadline to comment is April 30. If you have any questions, please don’t hesitate to email or call us. 
 
You can send one email and include all three of the following recipients in the TO line:
 
Email Subject:  # SWF-2011-00483 & # SWG-2014-00412
I am a landowner impacted by Texas Central’s proposed high-speed rail project (HSR). I am submitting this comment in regards to the certification and permitting activities being performed by the US Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) & Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ) for the HSR (# SWF-2011-00483 & # SWG-2014-00412). Texas Central does not have the right to exercise eminent domain on my property to conduct a survey or for any other purpose. As a result, I do not consent to my property being surveyed by the USACE & TCEQ for the HSR, nor do I consent to the use of any information concerning my property for the USACE’s or TCEQ’s certification or permitting activities related to the HSR. To the extent information concerning my property has already been used or included by the USACE or TCEQ as part of any such activities, please remove it from consideration immediately. Any survey or further use of information concerning my property on Texas Central’s behalf will be considered an illegal trespass. 
Please record this comment in the administrative record.
 
Sincerely,
Your Name
Street Address
City
 
I hope you and your family are well during these difficult times. Please let us know if we can be of assistance to you.
 
Truly for Texas,
Kyle Workman
Chairman and President
Texans Against HSR